Yesterday I read Thomas Hawke’s post about Media Center Sucking and didn’t know what to think. I can entirely empathize with how he feels. I also can understand and appreciate Charlie Owen’s response.
Here is my take. I still remember the day I got Media Center working. I had a TiVo for 2 years and loved it to death. I went to great lengths to build a Media Center 1.0 back when you could not do so. I had to scrounge a remote and tuner card from a buddy (who shall remain nameless). There was no such thing as “dogfooding” back then. But I made it happen, and I watched the internal Microsoft community grow around Media Center. My internal blog at Microsoft got a lot of traffic cause at one point I had the authoritative 50 step process on how to build your own Media Center box.
A lot has changed since then. Building a MCE box is a cake. I no longer use TiVo. Two versions have shipped since v1 (once a year) and I dogfooded each one. When Media Center Extender went into alpha I was one of 5 people selected for dogfood (5 people outside the MCE team). I was also selected to dogfood Portable Media Center. I was on all the DLs giving tons of feedback, filing bugs, and helping make the product great. I was incredibly happy and excited about the work the team was doing. I truly love my Media Center, but things have changed. I can claim credit for the fact that on a DVI based 16:9 plasma, the stretch/zoom modes work perfectly
. I filed a bunch of bugs in this area. Same goes for 5.1 discrete audio support from WMV and AC3 audio. Finally I spent a lot of my time building support for my Front Panel Display, and giving the team tons of feedback about the APIs.
This year was the first year I did not dogfood Media Center. Why? I am addicted to high-def, and I get my high-def from comcast. I no longer use my Media Center as a DVR. I do use the extender to watch TV in my bedroom, and I do use it to record shows that are only offered in lo-def (like the daily show). But I pretty much stopped using it for timeshifting. The comcast solution is a piece of crap, but it works most of the time and allows me to timeshift HD, and that is the high order bit these days.
I still use Media Center for my music, photos, and DiVX stuff. But not much more. So I can understand how Thomas feels, and I can see Charlie’s perspective. But the reality is, my Media Center has turned into an appliance, and it can be so much more. Not having the hi-def cable support is truly unfortunate. I know the team is working hard on this, but the reality is, if I had to deal with the cable industry for my job, I’d quit.
PS - I do wish Windows Media Player was a whole lot more usable. The fact that there is no word wheeling is just weak. iTunes is phenomenally easier to use (but I still refuse to install it on my PC cause it's has all these useless running processes for no good reason).