I have to say, I have never been so impressed with a piece of technology than the $449 Netbook I purchased last week. It is replacing a Fujitsu P7120 that I purchased in 2006 for $1,900.
How is this even possible? I have no idea, but I had to write about this.
Over the past year or so a new class of PC was born, and coined Netbook. Early on, these laptops were generally powered by Linux, had 4GB or 8GB SSD drives and ran extremely slow with tiny keyboards and 8 inch screens. Nothing for me to get excited about. In a former life, these things were called Ultra Mobile PC (UMPC) and they were super slow (like the Samsung Q1 and Q1 Ultra). My first experience with these things turned me off. They also cost about $800, or $1300 for a high end OQO.
However, in the past few months, something remarkable has happened. The technology got better, they started shipping with Windows XP, and they also started shipping with the Intel Atom processor and prices are UNDER $500, in some cases UNDER $400.
It’s pretty significant that these machines are now shipping with Windows XP. Why? Cause the return rate on the Linux Netbooks is 4x the Windows laptops as mentioned by the MSI Director of U.S. Sales (the maker of the MSI Wind) in this interview by laptopmag.com.
We have done a lot of studies on the return rates and haven’t really talked about it much until now. Our internal research has shown that the return of netbooks is higher than regular notebooks, but the main cause of that is Linux. People would love to pay $299 or $399 but they don’t know what they get until they open the box. They start playing around with Linux and start realizing that it’s not what they are used to. They don’t want to spend time to learn it so they bring it back to the store. The return rate is at least four times higher for Linux netbooks than Windows XP netbooks.
What’s even better about these new class of Netbooks is that they are perfectly capable of running Vista with Aero Glass as notebook review recently wrote about.
While Windows Vista gets a lot of bad press these days, it isn't always the worst operating system choice for notebooks. In our quick testing of Windows Vista on the MSI Wind, not only did it give us a nice bump in performance, but we also gained battery life. For a compact subnotebook you really can't ask for more, especially on the battery life front. For now I think Vista is here to stay on our MSI Wind (well before we have to send it back).
My wife has been using our aging Fujitsu P7120 for the past year and it’s been showing it’s age. For one thing the battery only lasts 20 minutes and it’s extremely slow and it can’t run Vista well. What better way to fix a problem like this than to whip out the credit card and spend some money?
I did a bunch of research and getting a Netbook seemed perfect. We are going to be traveling for 3 weeks this December and need a small and light laptop as an accessory for my Digital SLR and my iPhone. Oh, we also need a web browser to check email and such. I don’t plan to bring my work laptop with me since I won’t be doing any work, and at 5 pounds it’s a bit heavy. So a 3 pound laptop that costs $449? not a tough decision.
So I narrowed my selection down to:
I crossed the Lenovo off the list because it ships with 512MB of Ram and a 3-cell battery (and no option to order a 6-cell battery yet). The MSI Wind with the 6 cell battery is near impossible to find, and finally, Amazon started selling the Asus Eee PC 1000H for $449, a good $40 cheaper than anyone else at the time… and I do love Amazon. [note: it appears Amazon is out of stock of the 1000H 60GB drive for $449, wait for it to come back in stock].
Each of these laptops have similar specs.
- 10 inch 1024 x 600 screen
- 80 GB SATA hard drive
- Intel Atom 1.6 Ghz processor
- 512MB – 1 GB of RAM
- WebCam
- Bluetooth (Lenovo S10 does not)
- WiFi (Asus has 802.11n while the others are b/g)
- Ethernet 10/100
Furthermore, they all have smaller keyboards. Of the bunch, the Asus has the larger keyboard at about 92% of full, while the Lenovo’s is much smaller at about 86%.
Also, I wanted as much battery I could get, so 6-cell was a requirement.
The Asus was the heaviest of the bunch (3.1 pounds) but when you factor travel weight, the difference becomes tiny as the Asus has an extremely tiny and light power brick. It’s the smallest power brick I’ve seen for a laptop.
The real story to this Netbook though is the Intel Atom processor. Now I love Intel as much as the next geek, but this processor is stunning. Coupled with the Intel GMA 950 graphics chip it can run Vista using Aero Glass without any problems.
For comparison, most dual core laptop processors use about 35W of power. Desktop processors use quite a bit more like 65W. The Intel Atom chip uses 2.5W of power. Here is a graph to demonstrate just how profound this is.
For a laptop that I plan to use to backup my photos, surf the web, and write some documents, or blog posts, this seems like a reasonable tradeoff
.
In my experience so far, this thing is plenty fast, and in fact it smokes my Fujitsu P7120 which shipped with the original Pentium Centrino chip (which really got the ball rolling on some high performance low power laptops). It has all around better specs than something that shipped less than 3 years ago and for 1/4 the cost. The only real bummer of this laptop is that the screen resolution is less (1024 x 600 vs 1280 x 768), but everything else is faster and better. I expect it’s only a matter of time before we see higher resolution screens for the same price.
If you’re like me, and interested in the gory details about the Intel Atom chip, you can read the excellent article by Anand Lai Shimpi.
And for the low low price of about $32 you can upgrade your memory to 2GB. Simple throw away the 1GB chip in the Asus and replace with a single 2GB 200 soDIMM PC2-5300 memory.
And if you think this is exciting, next up from Asus, a MacBook Air thin netbook.
I’m really humbled by the fact that you can get a decent laptop for under $500. My guess is that these things are going to sell like hotcakes, especially among parents with school aged children.